No, Your Violence and Lack of Accommodation is Not Our Fault

So, a disabled woman set off the metal detector at an airport. This triggered additional screening. Her mother attempted to inform the TSA agents of her daughter’s needs. They ignored her. The woman became confused and tried to get away from the TSA agents. They tackled her to the ground and left her bloody. She was arrested (though the charges were later dropped.

Not surprisingly, the TSA and police are being sued over this. What I would like to talk about is the TSA’s defense of their actions. They are crying ignorance. Apparently, the woman’s mother telling them that her daughter is disabled and might become confused before the situation escalated was insufficient. They suggest that the woman and disabled people generally should call ahead to inform airport staff that they are disabled.

UM WHAT?

Not only is that not likely to have changed this situation. It is also an absurd burden to place on disabled people. We might as well hire town criers to precede us every where we go, ringing bells and yelling “Hear ye, hear ye, Cripple approaching”.

Now, I know that many disabled people do have to call airports ahead because they require assistance either navigating the airport or boarding the plane. I also know that for every person that I know who requires that assistance that I have heard at least one horror story. Stories that range from having there assistance requests lost (more or less reinforcing the idea that calling ahead was all that was required to avoid the violence exacted on that woman) to being left alone in the “accessibility lounge” for hours while being actively separated from travel companions.

It’s bad enough that systems aren’t in place to accommodate disabled people without advance warning (thus giving people an excuse to fall back on when a space isn’t accessible) but to suggest that we should have to announce our presence in situations we weren’t even expecting to require accommodations is absurd.

Violence against disabled people by law enforcement agencies is hardly rare. It is not just in airports. Should we also call the police non-emergency line every time that we leave our homes and provide them with a detailed itinerary and list of our diagnoses and symptoms? Just in case we have an unexpected interaction with police while we’re out?

I mean law enforcement (the TSA included) is totally equipped to keep track of every disabled person (and their specific needs) they might interact with in a given day; as long as we call ahead right? It’s not like there are very many disabled people or that our needs are particularly varied or complex.

The answer is clearly not to give people in positions of authority (particularly where they have training in responding with force) to be aware of the needs of disabled people. Particularly, in scenarios where there is someone trying to inform them of that fact.

It is not our responsibility to anticipate and stop violence against ourselves. We couldn’t if we tried. It’s a completely unrealistic expectation.

It is far more reasonable to expect people in power to be educated about disability and to listen when they are told that they are dealing with a disabled person and act appropriately.

It should go without saying that the appropriate action in this case was not violence.

 

Advertisements

7 responses to “No, Your Violence and Lack of Accommodation is Not Our Fault

  1. It is good to know that people are petitioning and speaking up about this[1].

    More training needs to be done to not only prevent abuse but to protect people who are really victims but are ignored and even arrested [2]. Even though people with disabilities, and even more so mental disabilities, are abused more, and are discouraged from defending themselves, punished for self defense.

    1. http://www.infowars.com/tsa-sued-for-beating-disabled-teen/
    2. https://federalsoup.com/articles/2016/06/28/doj-personnel-to-receive-training.aspx

    Like

  2. This poor woman. The TSA were brutal. It should never have happened. I hope she sues them.

    I travelled to America from Australia and had awful experiences with the TSA and customs because of my skin and cream. Questioned at customs about my face – more out of curiosity than anything – and my lack of fingerprints. Re TSA – I needed to carry my ointment (paraffin) with me. It’s prescribed from the doctor. I had 10 kg for 7 weeks. I had a doctors certificate and all containers were labelled, and it’s listed as safe for flying on the materials safety data sheet. I told all airlines prior. When I got to New Orleans, I was treated so badly. They wouldn’t allow my ointment as carry on , and even doubted whether it’s ok for stowaway. They told me my pharmacy labels and medical certificate might be counterfeit and id be treated like a terrorist until proven otherwise. I was worried I would be without my ointment for almost half my trip. I had previously called the TSA as I was advised in Chicago, but they wouldn’t note it down to prepare the TSA staff at the airport.

    It was 530 am, I was tired and hungry and in another country with no one believing my needs. I cried and swore. After almost an hour, they got a manager and it was ok for my ointment to travel with me. But it was an awful experience.

    Like

  3. “Should we also call the police non-emergency line every time that we leave our homes and provide them with a detailed itinerary and list of our diagnoses and symptoms? Just in case we have an unexpected interaction with police while we’re out?”
    Apparently they do have something for this in London, Ontario for people on the Autism Spectrum. :/

    Like

  4. Pingback: The Social Model of Disability in the Children’s Area - ALSC Blog

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s